Welcome to The Manhattan Well Diggers historical digging and networking site

About Us

We are a dedicated group of privy diggers, artists, collectors, researchers and educators who have an ongoing passion for salvaging and unearthing bottles and artifacts on private property here in New York City and sometimes further afield. In the manner that it is practiced by our group, historical digging, privy digging and dump digging basically, is neither garbology nor treasure hunting exclusively, nor does it claim to be or aspire to be academic archaeology of any kind. It is a niche pursuit in its own right, an avocation perhaps and maybe even an artistic expression of some kind when looked at from a certain angle. One which involves various aspects of a variety of different researching and 'hunting' and locating and excavating techniques, depending on ever-present time and terrain constraints and other inherent challenges and obstacles associated with this type of salvage work.One of our main focuses is to locate dwellings from the mid 19th century which were built without the luxury of modern plumbing and therefore most likely have a subterranean privy vault somewhere on the original property.

These vaults (loosely referred to as "wells" here in New York City), which are generally constructed of fieldstone, schist, brownstone or red brick, sometimes contain shards of pottery, glass, and other objects which were thrown into the opening in the ground under the privy while they were active as everyday household latrines. De facto trash holes for discarding broken tableware items or rancid foodstuffs from the kitchen or soiled rags, an abundance of clam and oyster shells, food bones and small animal carcasses, etc. and also a seemingly endless assortment of common and essentially valueless old bottles. These things obviously no longer served any useful purpose to the occupants of the house and therefore were deemed junk and thrown away.

Most of the trash holes we locate are slated for demolition
to one extent or another and those that aren't have nearly always been "disturbed" already. Commonly this took place right around the time the home received indoor or modern plumbing of one kind or another. The emptying and refilling process, which is referred to as 'privy dipping' oftentimes went straight to the bottom of the vault with no mercy. Furthermore, while emptying and then refilling the hole with fresh material, such as coal-ash from a nearby factory or other business or just plain dirt, etc. this technique had a nasty tendency of damaging, destroying or removing the intact bottles and other sought after containers along with the entire contents of the privy chambers (the wells) we explore.

In addition to the privy-vaults, i.e., privy-chambers, wells, pits or just plain privies (essentially all the exact same thing in practice though each varying considerably in width, depth, volume, contents and location and so on) we also dig out cisterns, bottle dumps and landfills whenever they can be pinpointed and are available to us. These can occasionally contain rarer or scarcer bottles depending on the particular dump or landfill site being pursued but all too often are generally from a time that did not have many hand or mold blown bottles around anymore to throw away (1915-1925 or even later). Additionally, most of the more obvious and presumably better dumps containing 1850s-1880s period bottles were dug through and exhausted by the enthusiastic pioneers of this hobby or destroyed and/or made inaccessible during the last several decades by development work, etc.

Bottle digging and hunting as we know it can be traced to the late 1960s or thereabouts. Privy digging commencing around the same time. By the 1970s and 80s avid digging and collecting clubs were everywhere. As a result not much that's truly remarkable is usually found within those particular tailings and for the most part unspoiled or worthwhile sites are no longer easy to find. However, from two decades of experience and literally hundreds of digs along the way, we humbly admit that there's always plenty of exceptions to that general rule just waiting to be uncovered when the time is ripe and the spade hits just right. Ironically, it can be construction, demolition and excavation projects which occasionally reveal good dumps, landfills and even privies containing antique bottles to the knowledgeable, diligent or just plain fortunate seeker today.

The stories, photos and bottles on this site, are meant to convey in part some of the more gratifying results of a timeless theme 'the pursuit of discovery.' This taking place in the context of a rather inglorious, often totally misunderstood and arguably monetarily thankless activity but one which we are nonetheless committed to.

__________________________________________________________________________________________________



Highway construction site off Park Row where
an 18th century privy was discovered. Located near the entrance to the Brooklyn Bridge it is arguably one of the more historic areas in New York City. Starting in the mid 19th century it was one of the most densely populated places on earth. The dates of the latest items in the privy were circa 1830s. Presumably whatever stood here was most likely gone before the area became swollen with multitudes arriving daily from across the pond. Something which was well underway by the end of the 1840s, continuing for many decades thereafter.

This section of Park Row (a street which ran through the infamous Five Points at one time) was partially layed over an 18th century woodlined privy. It was characteristically sparse regarding bottles. Hidden snugly therein for ages were only a handful of vials or small bottles from the mid-late 1700s to about 1810, an 1820s black glass quart, 1 plain gallon size crock, 2 light green ointment pots, 1 chocolate glazed ointment pot and not much else that was intact. Noteworthy as well were several burlap sacks worth of tantalizing early shards and the neck-less remains of an embossed, dark olive-green, rectangular medicine (?) bottle displaying Hendries London on one panel. The 6'x6'x4' privy chamber was literally jam packed with tableware shards, broken or damaged food and beverage containers, etc.


Items from the rivers edge at low tide,
London. Many basically spanning the
entire 18th & 19th centuries
and in
some cases even earlier.

Artifact hunting on the Thames during a 2 week
excursion by bus, boat, foot, car & train throughout
England, Scotland & Ireland, 2006.

Assisting outside the 7' x 16' foot privy hole during
Winter in downtown Manhattan, frigid with
20 below zero wind-chill.

Tim emerging from an 1850s privy in Brooklyn, 1997. *The outdoor flush toilet in use here between 1880-1920s, which emptied into the sewer line in the street, was built directly over this old privy.

A rare eye-popping cache containing nearly a full dozen intact clay beers from roughly 1875. These were almost missed due to the fact that they were lying at the bottom of the privy, outside the wall.

Exploring in a bottle dump in the Andes in Colombia,
2004.

Sight searching (see figure back left) in Northern
France 2003. Discoveries dated from
approximately 1590s-1750s.

Reconstructions from four privies on contiguous sites in Greenwich Village, New York City, excavated in 1998.

Cobalt medicine bottle from one of the most recent privy digs in Harlem. A string of pits which produced more than 150 intact bottles from varying periods.

Working against the clock in Harlem at the very top of a privy, 2007, as large scale excavation equipment inches ever closer to this site.


A moment of repose lying inside a New York City privy, downtown, with the first soda of the dig. What was to be an 8 foot wide 14 foot deep hole (aka The Gape-Mouth) containing 100 bottles from the 1840s
to just after the Civil War.

False teeth, a thimble, a dolls arm, several shell buttons, a flow blue shard and an assortment of medicinal vials which eventually numbered over 40,
from a woodlined privy outside of New York City.

This Brooklyn privy was finally located, with the assistance of a sledgehammer, after a grueling search of the concrete covered backyard.

Reconstructions from four privies on contiguous sites in Greenwich Village, New York City, excavated in 1998.

 

A plethora of sodas & beers from a single privy in Manhattan, 2007.

At the beginning of one of several privy
digs conducted on an early 19th century
property which was leveled soon after.

These are what was left from the original privy of a house built in 1816. As stated earlier most privies we dig have already been disturbed long before we get there (dipped). Of the many bottles, cups, crocks, jugs, plates, pipes, etc. implied from this assortment
of shards, nothing more remains. Moreover, like so many others, this entire site was bulldozed right
after this photo was taken in 2002.

Valerie, on loan from MSDW, exploring in an 1850s brick-lined Brooklyn privy, 1998.

Directly from a New York City privy a hard to come
by oval ten pin embossed with an "F", circa 1850,
being held by it's discoverer on the roof of her
Manhattan residence, 2000.

New York Public Library Map Room, 2002. Researching the history of property lines and original building details pertaining to ongoing demolition projects around New York City.

Surrendering to the unrelenting 100 degree New York City Heat Wave of 2007, deep within a fairly large privy vault, measuring a total of 7 feet across at its widest point.

Central Mexico, 2000. Ruins in a reservoir where
we researched.

Filling in an 1850s & 60s period privy vault which
was uncharacteristically located in the middle of
a driveway on Staten Island, near what was
generally referred to as Factory Lake, during
the 19th century, 2002.

Encountering dozens of intact bottles while digging in one small portion of a monster hole, Manhattan, 2006.



Vigorously tearing through remarkably solidified topsoil (concretion) and debris in what was a parking lot for
many decades, as a definitive privy outline swiftly
makes itself known.



Cache of bottles in situ, circa 1865-75, Manhattan. *Including an amber example of Hyatt's Life Balsam N-Y Double Strength,
back center, 2004.

From a New York City privy dig, 1999.

Laser lights from Ground Zero commemorating the WTC.

Home

© 1997  The Manhattan Well Diggers. - All rights reserved.